Fulfillment & Warehousing Insights | TFL Blog

How To Switch 3PL Providers: Warning Signs & Key Considerations

Written by Rick Nelson | 10. 5. 2026

As an eCommerce retailer, you already know what a third-party logistics (3PL) provider does-and what happens when yours falls short. Perhaps you’ve outgrown your current provider, or recurring fulfillment errors and rising costs are cutting into your margins.

Whatever the reason, switching 3PLs may be necessary to keep your operations running efficiently and support your next stage of growth.

When Is It Time To Switch 3PL? 8 Warning Signs

Time for an upgrade? Need to feel more valued as a customer? Whatever your reason for considering a change, here are eight warning signs that can help you decide when to switch 3PLs.

1. Consistently Making Mistakes

There are always going to be some mistakes when it comes to fulfillment. But when your 3PL screws up orders consistently, this reflects poorly on your company. After all, most consumers will blame the brand they know, not the fulfillment center.

Whether your logistics company is shipping damaged goods, sending products to the wrong addresses, or losing products altogether, if it happens too often, it’s time to start evaluating options to change your fulfillment provider.

2. Failure To Evolve

Ecommerce moves at lightning-fast speeds and is constantly evolving (along with customer expectations).

  • Is your 3PL moving just as quickly?
  • Are they finding more efficient ways to get your product to your customer?
  • Are they staying ahead of the curve with advancements in technology?

If they can’t keep up and haven’t made improvements in a long time, or have failed to streamline processes since day one, they’re a reactive company. And, to be successful in this business, 3PLs need to be proactive.

3. No International Facilities

Many eCommerce companies begin with a domestic fulfillment provider. However, with global online shoppers reaching more than 2.77 billion, eventually, they decide they want to tap into that international audience.

However, if their 3PL only operates within United States borders and doesn’t understand international trade rules and regulations, many eCommerce companies can feel stuck.

So, if you’re ready to take a bite out of the international market, it’s best to work with a logistics company that can support international shipping, customs requirements, and, where needed, fulfillment from overseas facilities.

4. Not Scalable Enough

Many startups and small eCommerce companies can handle logistics on their own at the beginning but eventually upgrade to a small, local third-party logistics company to move the business out of their home. However, increasing sales can lead to outgrowing even the 3PL provider.

If your business is scaling rapidly and your 3PL can’t handle the abundance of inventory, SKUs, or orders, it’s time to find a fulfillment partner with greater capacity. You’ll want to make sure they have more than enough warehouse space for your current inventory – and future inventory as you continue to grow.

5. Lack Of Support

Being able to handle returns, exchanges, and refunds is just as important as order fulfillment. However, not all 3PLs offer this service or have people available 24/7 to take calls and offer support. And that’s just for your customers; what if you need more tech support, or have an inventory emergency?

It’s important to make sure that the 3PL you switch to offers the amount of customer and client support you need.

6. Outdated Technology

First things first: the 3PL provider you choose must have order management software to give you insight into each order, from the moment it’s received until the moment it’s delivered. Of course, tracking orders is pretty basic; since you’re upgrading, be sure their software can sync with your software and your shopping cart to save you from having to manually upload orders.

Finally, you may want to consider a 3PL provider that allows you to create customized packaging and inserts, shipping labels, and packing slips right through your portal in their system.

7. Too Many Customer Complaints

A 2026 study found that 76% of global shoppers won't buy from an online retailer if they don't trust its delivery or returns provider. So, if your website or other review sites are being bombarded with bad reviews due to the delivery experience, or you’re seeing lots of negative social media posts, reconsider your fulfillment and shipping strategy and your 3PL.

8. Overpriced

Sometimes you get what you pay for. However, if you're paying premium pricing for fulfillment, and the company isn't providing top-notch support, transparent technology, and great customer experiences, you’re probably not getting your money’s worth.

You should also be sure your 3PL has relationships with major carriers; a good partner will have negotiated rates and may be able to pass some of those savings on to you.

Lastly, it will benefit you to look for a logistics company that operates out of multiple locations, so they can ship products from the facility closest to the customer (the fewer shipping zones a product travels across, the less it will generally cost).

 

What To Consider Before Changing 3PL Providers

Before changing 3PL providers, you also need to evaluate the contractual, financial, technical, and operational requirements that could affect the transition.

1. Contractual Obligations & Transition Timeline

Review your current agreement terms, required termination notice periods, and any exit obligations. Establish a realistic implementation timeline with sufficient time buffers, ideally scheduling the transition during a lower-volume period to minimize operational disruptions.

2. Total Switching Costs

When switching 3PLs, account for one-time transition expenses beyond standard fulfillment rates. Calculate costs such as outbound inventory removal fees from your previous provider, freight transportation to the new facility, Warehouse Management System (WMS) setup charges, and dual-warehouse storage fees during the overlap period.

3. Specialized Facility & Handling Requirements

Examine your product and handling specifications rather than general warehouse capacity alone. Verify whether prospective facilities support specialized requirements such as temperature-controlled storage, HAZMAT compliance, lot or serial number tracking, custom kitting, or specialized storage equipment.

4. Technology Integration & Pre-Launch Testing

Before going live, conduct end-to-end test orders, verify API data mapping, and check inventory synchronization across your sales channels and WMS. Resolve any discrepancies before transferring live order processing to the new provider.

5. Implementation Ownership & Coordination

Establish clear responsibilities across both teams for the 3PL changeover. Confirm that the new provider assigns a dedicated implementation manager to oversee project dependencies, coordinate system setup, and maintain consistent communication throughout the transition.

How To Switch 3PLs: From Provider Selection To Transition

So, how do you switch fulfillment providers without unnecessarily disrupting your operations?

Here are four steps to help you manage the process, from evaluating alternatives to completing the changeover.

Interview Potential Logistics Companies

After you’ve researched potential providers, some of the questions you’ll want to consider asking in order to make a good 3PL comparison include:

  1. How are you different from our current 3PL?
  2. Will you be able to scale with my business as it grows?
  3. Will your technology work with ours? Will your software integrate with my online store?
  4. How will your software help me improve my business?
  5. How many fulfillment centers do you have, and where are they located?
  6. Will you be able to ship from multiple locations to cut down on shipping costs and expedite deliveries?
  7. Can you support me as I expand internationally?
  8. Can you provide me with a 3PL provider cost comparison?

Review Your Supply Chain

After you’ve selected a new 3PL provider, you’ll need to look at your supply chain and adjust transit times for inventory to be sent from your manufacturer to the 3PL. This can impact when you need to reorder inventory and the quantity, especially if the new fulfillment center is a greater distance from the manufacturer or your existing distribution points.

If you’re switching from one fulfillment center to a 3PL with multiple fulfillment centers, there will be some additional numbers to crunch, but a good logistics company will help with that. Lastly, be sure to communicate these changes with your manufacturers to ensure deliveries make it to the right fulfillment center.

Begin The 3PL Transition

Once you’ve decided to switch 3PLs, you may want to move all your inventory right away (out with the old, in with the new). However, don’t jump the gun. Keeping inventory in your old fulfillment center while shipping inventory to your new 3PL helps prevent stockouts and backorders while you’re getting set up.

Once the new 3PL is operational and you’ve got a full load of inventory at the new facility, you may just want to run a sale to clear out the old inventory with your previous 3PL to avoid having to transfer the product. Just make sure your backend technology is set up to route those orders to the old 3PL until the inventory is cleared out.

Notify Your Customers

Even with a seamless transition, there’s always the potential for the unexpected, such as a temporary delay in shipping. So, let your customers know that you’re switching 3PLs to provide a better experience and more shipping options, but that it could result in a temporary delay during the changeover.

Customers prefer transparency from businesses, so make note of the change on the website, social media, and so on to keep them in the loop. This shows that you value them, and again, you can let them know the switch is designed with them in mind.

Customers prefer transparency from businesses, so make note of the change on the website, social media, and so on to keep them in the loop. This shows that you value them, and again, you can let them know the switch is designed with them in mind.

Make A Switch To The Fulfillment Lab

Although The Fulfillment Lab is usually sourced as a 3PL service developer, we don’t like to box ourselves in! We like to think of ourselves as a customizable 3PL, working with our clients to best meet their logistics and fulfillment needs. We want to be a true partner, not just a provider.

Here are some of the services we offer:

  • Customized mass-volume fulfillment
  • On-demand product capabilities
  • Proprietary fulfillment software
  • Global shipping from 14 locations
  • Complete order transparency
  • White and private label manufacturing
  • Dynamic integration with shopping carts
  • Returns Management
  • Lightning-fast scalability
  • Fulfillment marketing

Have a specific question or are you ready to get the best fulfillment experience on the planet?

Let’s connect!

FAQs

What Is 2PL, 3PL, 4PL, And 5PL?

  • 2PL (Second-Party Logistics): Asset-based carriers that own the ships, planes, or trucks to physically move goods from point A to point B.
  • 3PL (Third-Party Logistics): External providers handling day-to-day operations like warehousing, picking, packing, and shipping.
  • 4PL (Fourth-Party Logistics): Non-asset strategic managers overseeing a company's entire supply chain and coordinating multiple 3PLs.
  • 5PL (Fifth-Party Logistics): Tech-driven network integrators organizing complex global e-commerce supply chains.

Is Amazon A 3PL Or 4PL?

Amazon primarily operates as a 3PL through Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), handling inventory storage, order fulfillment, shipping, and returns for third-party sellers. Although it offers advanced logistics coordination, Amazon is not generally classified as a traditional 4PL provider.

What Are The Disadvantages Of Using A 3PL?

The main disadvantages of using a 3PL include reduced direct control over fulfillment, additional service and storage fees, potential integration challenges, and dependence on an external provider. Poor communication, inventory inaccuracies, or shipping delays can also affect customer satisfaction.

What Does Transferred To 3PL Mean?

Transferred to 3PL means that inventory or shipping responsibilities have been handed over to a third-party logistics provider. For businesses, this can mean moving stock to an outsourced warehouse or transferring fulfillment operations to a 3PL. In package tracking, it usually means the shipment has been passed to another logistics company, often a local courier, for the next stage of delivery.

Who Are The Top 3PL Providers?

Top global 3PL providers include DSV, DHL Supply Chain, Kuehne+Nagel, CEVA Logistics, Nippon Express, GXO Logistics, and C.H. Robinson. Notable U.S. ecommerce 3PL providers include The Fulfillment Lab, ShipBob, and ShipMonk. The right 3PL provider depends on your business needs, geographic coverage, pricing, and service specialization.

How Do You Change Fulfillment Providers?

Changing fulfillment providers involves selecting a new partner, reviewing your existing contract, coordinating inventory transfers, integrating systems, and testing order fulfillment before completing the switch.